| Career |
WINS |
| Clay McConkey (2008-Present) |
105 |
| Harry Dean Blair (1945-1964) |
103 |
| Mike Kraft (1988-2013, 2018-Present) |
82 |
| Doug Sluser (1985-2009) |
80 |
| Robert Newell (1929-1947) |
79 |
| Josh Caruso (2000-Present) |
78 |
| Harvey Kreps (1933-1952) |
77 |
| Tom Hammerton (1980-1997) |
73 |
| William Stewart (1956-1969) |
72 |
| Mike Molchin (1977-1997) |
70 |
| William Reising (1963-1981) |
70 |
| Don Wyss (1952-1987) |
64 |
| Robert Schmitt (1948-1972) |
62 |
| Ennio Arboit (1936-1951) |
59 |
| Bruce Kneebone (1981-1987) |
55 |
| Leonard Bailey (1948-1957) |
55 |
| Randy Randolph (1928-1937) |
55 |
| Rich Trau (1969-1980) |
55 |
| Charles Heer (1928-1952) |
53 |
| Rick Dissman (1979-1994) |
52 |
| Ted Rowe (2000-2013, 2018, 2024-Present) |
51 |
| Ralph Stephens (1977-1984) |
49 |
| Kirk Woiwode (1976-1985) |
48 |
| Pat Grafton (1963-1975) |
48 |
| Fred Geick (1918-1946) |
47 |
| Steve Hoak (1966-1984) |
47 |